Asana Video Proofing: How Agencies Get Client Sign Off on Video
Asana is a great tracker and a poor place to review a moving picture. Here is how I keep the task in Asana, put timestamped client review in one link, and match statuses and versions on both sides.
Asana video proofing at most agencies happens in the comment box at the bottom of a task, which is the one corner of the tool that has no idea which second of the film anyone means. The client watches the cut in another tab, comes back and types "logo near the end feels small, and the music gets loud in the middle", and then an editor scrubs back and forth trying to work out which end and which middle, right, and nobody ever writes that lost time down as a cost.
I ran it exactly that way for a long stretch in my own video editing agency, and the tracker was never the problem, because the part that kept breaking was a client trying to describe a moment inside a moving picture using a text box built for words. So when people search for Asana video proofing, I'm pretty sure most of them are hoping there's a setting they missed, and what they find is Asana's pages about proofing images and documents, sitting next to forum threads from video teams asking for more.
This post is for the producer or creative ops lead who is staying on Asana, and honestly should, but who still needs clients to leave timestamped notes and give a clear sign-off on video, so I'll walk through what Asana proofing does and then the exact setup I use around it.
Asana video proofing: what the built-in tool covers today
Asana's proofing, the way its own help centre and guide describe it, is built around still work, where you click a spot on an image or a one-page document and leave a note pinned there, which is really really good for a banner, a social static, a one-page deck and so on. Next to those help pages, the results for this exact search show two community forum threads where video teams ask for proper video proofing, plus tutorials about adding feedback to images. If Asana has added more video support by the time you read this, check their help centre for your plan, because my argument here doesn't depend on it.
To be fair, still proofing is a sensible home for the storyboard and style frames at the start of a job. The trouble starts the day the animatic with rough timing turns up, because that's the first deliverable where timing is the thing being judged.
The catch here is that a still image has two coordinates, while a video has a third, time, and a fourth, how long the problem lasts, since a music swell isn't a single frame at all. Video review also needs the client to press play without learning your tools, each new cut to sit on top of the old one, and the editor to land on the exact frame. Basically, even a perfect pin on a still solves one of those jobs, right, and the rest are where the rounds actually get lost.
For the basics there's my explainer on what video proofing actually means, and my list of Asana integrations for creative teams covers the wider stack, so here I'm staying narrow, on asana proofing for videos and the sign-off at the end of it.
Why video needs time based comments
Say the job is a 60-second launch film for a skincare brand plus three 15-second vertical cutdowns, cut at 25 frames per second. Quick illustrative math: 60 seconds at 25 fps is 1,500 frames, so when the brand manager writes "the logo near the end feels small" and means the last twelve seconds, that's 300 candidate frames, and the editor has to guess which one she paused on, whether she meant the end card or the bottle, and whether small means scale or weight.
A time-based comment removes the guessing, because the note carries its own address. In PlayPause she clicks the moment and her comment sticks to 00:00:52:10, which is hours, minutes, seconds and frames, the same timecode your editor sees in the timeline. For the music she drags a range comment across 00:00:22 to 00:00:31 instead of writing "the middle", and on the logo she draws a circle on the paused frame, so the editor knows it's scale without a follow-up message. That's what I mean by time-coded annotations for video, and it's the honest answer for anyone searching asana video annotation, because a note on a video only means something once it's pinned to time.
logo near the end feels small, so the editor scrubs through 300 frames guessing which moment and which logo
pinned to 00:00:52:10 with a circle drawn on the lockup and a reply thread underneath it
The part people underrate is what happens after the note. Say my editor isn't sure, so he replies right under the comment and @mentions the brand manager to ask whether the circle means the end card or the bottle, and she answers on that same frame, so the question settles where the evidence sits instead of in an Asana thread pointing at a file nobody can see from there, does that make sense, right.
Where client review should live when the project lives in Asana
The rule I landed on after a lot of messy months is that each tool owns one question. Asana owns who is doing what by when, which is the core of project management as a discipline, and a board with sections shows a producer the whole project at a glance. The review link owns what needs changing in this version and whether the client has approved it, and the moment one tool tries to answer both, you get half the notes in Asana and half in email, with an editor stitching them together at eleven at night.
So for asana video review, I don't drag the client into Asana at all. To be very honest, most of my clients would rather not join yet another workspace, so they get one PlayPause link, open it in a browser with no account and no install, press play and click the moments that feel off. The Asana task holds that link in its description, which is why I don't depend on any integration here, right, because a pasted link has never once broken on me.
Asana should know who is doing what by Friday, the review link should know what the client said at 00:00:52:10, and neither one should try to do the other job.
Two things keep the team in the loop without anyone living in Asana comments. The Slack connection posts every comment to a channel, so the producer sees notes as they come in, and the who-watched analytics show who opened the link, when and from which city, so before I chase anyone I already know whether they've watched. The client approval workflow for video page lays out the stages, and creative project management with review shows how both sides sit together.
Setting up the handoff from Asana task to review link
This is the part that actually changes behaviour, right, because a handoff that lives in the producer's head gets done differently every single time. Every deliverable gets its own Asana task, so the launch film is one task and each cutdown is another, and each of those tasks points to exactly one card in PlayPause.
The task description is where I'm strict, because it's the first thing anyone opens when they pick the task up cold on a Monday, so I keep the same five lines in it, in the same order, every time.
- The PlayPause review link for this deliverable
- The current version, such as MV2
- The review deadline and the round number out of the rounds in the SOW
- The one person on the client side who can approve
- The date and version of final approval once it lands
For the skincare film, filled in, that's the PlayPause link on line one, "MV2" on line two, "notes due Thursday 5pm, round 2 of 3" on line three, the brand manager's name on line four, and line five left empty until approval lands. That empty line is useful in itself, right, because anyone glancing at the task can tell it isn't signed off yet.
The email that goes out with the link matters as well, and I've shared my wording in the client approval email template. Password-protected links and instant link revoking are on every plan, so if the link gets forwarded to someone who shouldn't see an unreleased product, I revoke it and paste a fresh one into the task. Share links last 30 days on Creator, 90 days on Agency and never expire on Enterprise, which matters when a task sits in Client review for five weeks because the client's CMO is travelling.
On the editor side, the Premiere Pro panel shows PlayPause comments inside Premiere, and clicking one jumps the playhead to that exact frame, so nobody retypes 00:00:52:10. The editor can upload the next cut from the timeline, pairing is done with a code, and I've gone deeper on that loop in syncing timestamped comments to Premiere. Editors cutting in Resolve or Final Cut Pro export, upload and review the same way, then work through the frame-accurate notes inside their own edit.
Frame-accurate note, everyone sees the exact same thing.
Matching Asana sections to review statuses
This is where most setups quietly drift apart, because the Asana board says Client review while the review link shows the client finished two days ago, and the producer decides off whichever one they opened first. The fix is boring, which is using the same words on both sides. PlayPause has custom statuses on every plan, so my Asana sections and my card statuses both read Internal review, Client review, Changes requested and Approved, word for word.
Then there's one rule about direction, and trust me on any level, it holds the whole thing together. The review status changes first, right, because that's where the evidence is, the Asana section follows within the same working hour, and only the producer moves tasks between sections. So when my editor sets the card to Changes requested, the producer drags the task across and writes one line in it, something like "MV2, seven notes, due Thursday". The mobile app helps here, because a producer on a shoot can change a status from their phone between setups.
Changes requested is also where I ask whether a note is a revision or new work, for instance "can we add a founder shot" isn't a revision, and I've written up how I handle that in billing late client requests. If your team uses Asana's approval tasks for asana creative approval, nobody ticks that approval until the card shows Approved on the version actually going out, because an approval that doesn't name the version will come back to bite you, you see what I mean here.
Keeping MV1 to MV4 attached to one Asana task
You probably know the other failure too, the task that slowly collects launch_final.mp4, launch_final_v2.mp4 and launch_FINAL_approved.mp4 as attachments, until the client leaves notes on the wrong one. This is a plain version control problem, the same one software teams solved years ago, and the answer is one history per deliverable with numbered versions and nothing floating loose.
In PlayPause that's a version stack, available from Creator up. MV2 goes onto the same card as MV1, MV3 after that, and MV1 with its notes stays in the stack, so the client can check the logo fix actually happened. On Agency and up, side-by-side compare lets the brand manager play MV3 against MV4 together, which is the fastest way I know, right, to stop the "did anything actually change" emails. For naming sequences inside the project, my sequence version naming convention keeps MV3 in the review matching MV3 in the timeline.
The Asana task carries only the review link and the current MV number, while MV1 to MV4 stack on one PlayPause card with their notes still attached.
Two Agency features earn their keep in this setup. Guest version upload lets a freelance editor outside the workspace put MV3 onto the card without an account, with their name and email collected, so the version lands in the stack instead of someone's inbox. Playbooks keep one document per client with their style rules, basically a living creative brief, so a new editor picking up the task in month three reads the brand's rules before touching the timeline. Whether the client ever gets the source files is a separate question, which I've answered in giving clients raw footage.
At the end of the day, the final approval should read like a record rather than a feeling, so when MV4 shows Approved, the producer writes the date and version into line five of the task, sends the paperwork from my video sign off form template, and only then moves the task to Delivered.
Frequently asked questions
Does Asana have video proofing built in?
Asana's proofing, as its own help centre and guide describe it, is built around images and one-page documents, where a note pins to a spot on a still page. Video teams have asked for more in Asana's community forum. Check the help centre for what your plan supports today, and if you need frame-accurate notes, range comments and version stacks, keep the review in a dedicated link and paste that link into the task, right.
Does PlayPause integrate with Asana?
PlayPause doesn't list an Asana integration, and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. My workflow doesn't need one anyway, because the share link goes into the task description, the statuses use the same words on both sides, and the Slack connection posts every comment to a channel. The one manual step is the producer moving the task, and that's deliberate, right, since one person owning that move keeps the board honest.
Do my clients need an Asana account or a PlayPause account to leave notes?
They need neither of them, right. The client opens the PlayPause link in a browser with no account and no install, clicks the moment, and leaves a comment that sticks to that frame, or drags a range comment, or draws on the paused frame. They never see your Asana workspace, which I actually prefer, because the client's job is to watch and react, not to learn how my agency organises its tasks and sections.
Which PlayPause plan suits an agency running projects from Asana?
For this setup, the features doing the heavy lifting are version stacks, the Slack connection and who-watched analytics, and those start on Creator at $9 a month for up to 10 members. If you want side-by-side compare, guest version upload from freelancers or a Playbook per client, that's Agency at $19 a month, and since pricing is flat per workspace, adding a producer within your member limit doesn't change the bill.
Try it on one live Asana project
If your Asana board is already doing its job and the review is the part leaking time, try this setup on a single live deliverable before you change anything else, with the review link pasted into its task and the four statuses copied across word for word. Every plan starts with a 7-day free trial, and the PlayPause plans and pricing page shows exactly what each tier includes.
So yeah. That's my way of saying it.
Saumyajit co-founded PlayPause after years watching review and approval quietly eat creative teams' deadlines. He writes about the workflow side of video, feedback, versioning, and getting to a clean sign-off.
Related resources
Keep reading
Bring your team into one review space
Centralize feedback, lock approvals, and deliver faster, start free today.
Sign Up for Free